Sylvain Goldberg explains the properties of lab-grown diamonds
Chemical vapor deposition (CVD) technology has accelerated over the last several years, and the rapidly improving techniques have produced large, high-quality near-colorless and colorless synthetic diamonds. Two samples over 3 carats were reported in early 2016 as the largest CVD synthetics. GIA recently tested a CVD-grown synthetic diamond that weighed over 5 carats, marking a significant milestone.
The 5.19 ct cushion modified brilliant measuring 10.04 × 9.44 × 6.18 mm (figure 1) was submitted to GIA’s Hong Kong laboratory for grading service. The stone was not disclosed as a synthetic diamond. Using the lab’s standard screening and testing processes, it was identified as CVD synthetic. Following examination, a GIA Identification Report was issued and the stone was inscribed on the girdle with the report number and the words “Laboratory Grown,” following GIA’s protocols for undisclosed synthetics.
This is the largest CVD synthetic diamond GIA has examined to date, and the largest reported in the jewelry industry. It had J-equivalent color grade and VS2-equivalent clarity, comparable to a high-quality natural counterpart. Natural-looking internal inclusions such as needles and clouds were the major features (figure 2). Strong graining and a fracture in the table were also clearly observed under the microscope. It is worth noting that black inclusions, often contained in synthetic diamond, were not found in this CVD specimen, which could have been mistakenly identified as natural based on microscopic examination alone. This case therefore highlights the importance of using advanced spectroscopic instruments as well as conventional gemological techniques to ensure an accurate identification.
Viewing the sample under a binocular microscope with cross-polarized light revealed irregular birefringence patterns with high-order interference colors, a common feature of CVD synthetic diamond (figure 3). Fluorescence images under the short-wave UV radiation of the DiamondView showed strong red fluorescence with irregularly distributed areas of violet-blue. The images also revealed a layered growth structure, indicating a start-stop cycling growth process typical of CVD synthesis. Up to six growth layers basically parallel to the table were identified from the fluorescence features. These multiple growth segments make it possible to grow such a thick sample.
Infrared absorption spectroscopy identified the sample as type IIa. Except for a very weak absorption at 1332 cm–1, no other absorption features (such as hydrogen-related defects) were detected. Photoluminescence (PL) spectra were collected at liquid nitrogen temperature with various excitation wavelengths. The SiV– doublet at 736.6 and 736.9 nm, a common feature of both CVD and HPHT synthetics and only rarely seen in natural diamond, was observed using 457, 514, and 633 nm laser excitation, suggesting the sample’s synthetic origin. Spectra acquired with 514 nm laser excitation also showed emissions from NV centers at 575.0 nm (NV0) and 637.0 nm (NV–), with the NV0 center dominating in intensity (figure 5). The occurrence of a weak emission pair at 596.5 and 597.2 nm, in combination with the absence of H3 emission, unequivocally identified this as an as-grown CVD synthetic diamond. No post-growth annealing had been applied to improve its color appearance.
CVD synthetics are available from several sources. The gemological and spectroscopic features of this 5.19 ct sample are very similar to those GIA has examined from Washington Diamonds (now known as WD Lab Grown Diamonds). As diamond growth techniques continue to advance, we expect to see more high-quality samples, both in size and clarity.
“Synthetic illusions remains just that…. illusions.”